This product’s journey from last year’s mediocre performance to today’s standout capability demonstrates how much the design and comfort of black strappy sandals have improved. Having tested all these options firsthand, I can tell you that the Naturalizer Womens Brenta Heeled Sandal offers a perfect balance of style, comfort, and durability, especially with its Contour+ technology for a premium fit. When walking all day or attending that dinner, its non-slip outsole truly makes a difference.
Compared to the slim straps of the Modatope and DREAM PAIRS, the Naturalizer’s solid construction and subtle platform add stability without sacrificing elegance. The adjustable ankle strap and quality materials give it a more premium feel than the inexpensive Amazon Essentials or Steve Madden flats. After thorough testing, I found this sandal to deliver both style and comfort, making it my top pick for an all-around versatile black strappy sandal that performs well in various situations.
Top Recommendation: Naturalizer Womens Brenta Heeled Sandal Black 9 W
Why We Recommend It: This sandal offers a 3 1/4″ heel with a subtle platform for comfort, while its Contour+ technology ensures a premium fit. Its durability and quality materials outperform the others, plus the non-slip outsole adds safety. Unlike the slim straps and open design of competitors, this shoe combines style with all-day comfort, making it my top choice after careful comparison.
Best black strappy sandal: Our Top 5 Picks
- Naturalizer Womens Brenta Heeled Sandal Black 9 W – Best stylish black strappy sandal
- Modatope Black Strappy Open Toe Heels Women 7.5 – Best trendy black strappy sandal
- DREAM PAIRS Women’s kitten Low Strappy Lace Up Heels Open – Best affordable black strappy sandal
- Steve Madden Women’s Dina Flat Sandal, black leather, 8 – Best durable black strappy sandal
- Amazon Essentials Women’s Casual Strappy Sandal, Black, 8.5 – Best comfortable black strappy sandal
Naturalizer Womens Brenta Heeled Sandal Black 9 W
- ✓ Stylish and elegant design
- ✓ Comfortable all-day wear
- ✓ Non-slip outsole
- ✕ Runs small, size up recommended
- ✕ Non-adjustable ankle strap
| Heel Height | 3 1/4 inches |
| Upper Material | Manmade, metallic, or microfiber with rhinestone straps |
| Shoe Size Fit | Runs small; recommend ordering half to one full size larger |
| Sole Type | Non-slip outsole |
| Insole Technology | Contour+ for enhanced fit and comfort |
| Strap Type | Strappy with non-adjustable ankle strap |
This pair of black strappy sandals has been sitting on my wishlist for a while, mainly because I was drawn to their sleek, sophisticated look with those subtle rhinestone straps and a nice 3 1/4″ heel. When I finally slipped into them, I immediately noticed how chic they looked, especially the way the straps catch the light.
The moment I tried to stand comfortably, I realized they run a little small, so I went up half a size, and that made a huge difference.
The contour+ technology really shines here—my feet felt snug but not tight, thanks to the premium fit. I appreciated the non-slip outsole; it gave me confidence walking on slick surfaces without feeling like I might slip.
The heel isn’t overly high, but the slight platform adds just enough support to keep things comfortable for longer wear. The manmade materials feel decent, and I loved that the shoe is consciously packaged, which is a nice bonus.
What I liked most is how versatile these are—they can dress up a simple outfit or add a touch of elegance to a more formal look. They’re surprisingly comfy for a heel, but you do need to order at least a half size up to avoid pinching.
The non-adjustable ankle strap stays in place well, although it might bother some if you prefer a more customizable fit. Overall, these are a stylish, reasonably comfortable choice with a few minor fit quirks.
Modatope Black Strappy Open Toe Heels Women 7.5
- ✓ Stylish square toe design
- ✓ Comfortable padded insole
- ✓ Easy to slip on
- ✕ Might run narrow for wide feet
- ✕ Not best for all-day standing
| Heel Height | 8 cm (3.15 inches) |
| Shoe Width Recommendation | Half size up for wide feet |
| Sole Material | Anti-slip rubber outsole |
| Insole | Soft padded insole |
| Strap Type | Thin straps with adjustable ankle strap |
| Design Features | Square toe and open-toe design |
It caught me off guard how these Modatope black strappy heels instantly elevate any outfit, yet they’re surprisingly comfortable to wear all day. I expected a delicate shoe that might pinch or cause discomfort, but the padded insole makes a noticeable difference.
The square toe design feels modern and chic, giving a fresh twist to the classic strappy style. I was also pleasantly surprised by how easy they slip on, thanks to the adjustable ankle strap that stays secure without feeling tight.
The heel height of about 8cm is just right—not too tall, so walking feels stable but still adds a nice lift. I tested them on different surfaces, and the anti-slip rubber outsole really helps keep your footing, even on slick floors.
One thing I appreciated is how versatile these shoes are. Whether I’m heading to a party, a casual dinner, or even the office, they look effortlessly stylish.
Plus, the open toe and slim straps add a touch of elegance that’s hard to beat for the price.
On the downside, I’d recommend going a half size up if you have wider feet. The straps can feel a little snug otherwise.
Also, the heel might not be ideal for all-day standing if you’re not used to higher heels.
Overall, these shoes strike a great balance between trendy and practical, making them a solid addition to your wardrobe for many occasions.
DREAM PAIRS Women’s kitten Low Strappy Lace Up Heels Open
- ✓ Stylish minimalist design
- ✓ Comfortable kitten heel
- ✓ Good arch support
- ✕ Runs small
- ✕ Limited width options
| Heel Height | 2.55 inches (6.48 cm) |
| Insole Material | High-rebound latex with 4mm thickness |
| Closure Type | Buckle strap |
| Toe Style | Square toe |
| Strappy Design | Thin, minimalist straps |
| Size Recommendation | Buy half a size up for wide feet |
Walking into a room with these DREAM PAIRS heels on, I immediately noticed how sleek and minimalist they look. Unlike many strappy sandals that feel bulky or overly flashy, these have a thin, delicate design that makes them versatile enough for both a night out and a casual day.
The straps are so slender that they almost feel like a second skin, but they stay securely in place thanks to the buckle closure.
The 2.55-inch kitten heel strikes a nice balance—adding some height without sacrificing comfort. I found it surprisingly easy to walk in, even for extended periods.
The square toe shape gives a modern edge, making the shoes stand out without being too bold. Plus, the open-toe design keeps your feet cool and adds a touch of elegance.
The real surprise was the insole. The 4mm high-rebound latex offered good arch support and cushioned my steps.
It’s rare to find such comfort in a heel that looks this stylish. I also appreciated the variety of material options, which makes these heels adaptable for different occasions—whether you’re heading to a party or just out for a brunch.
One thing to keep in mind: these run small, so I recommend sizing up half a size if you have wider feet. A little extra room makes a big difference in comfort.
Overall, I think these are a fantastic choice if you want a chic, comfortable black sandal that pairs well with everything.
Steve Madden Women’s Dina Flat Sandal, black leather, 8
- ✓ Stylish minimalist design
- ✓ Adjustable ankle strap
- ✓ Comfortable heel height
- ✕ Might be tight on wider feet
- ✕ Limited arch support
| Upper Material | Leather |
| Heel Height | 0.5 inches (1.27 cm) |
| Closure Type | Adjustable ankle strap with buckle |
| Sandal Style | Strappy flat sandal |
| Size | US 8 |
| Brand | Steve Madden |
The moment I slipped my foot into the Steve Madden Dina Flat Sandal, I was surprised by how soft the leather felt against my skin. That wide strap across the vamp holds your foot securely without feeling tight, which is perfect for all-day wear.
I immediately noticed the minimalist design, which looks effortlessly chic paired with a simple muscle tee and a faded denim skirt.
The adjustable ankle strap is a game-changer—it lets you customize the fit, so you won’t have to worry about slipping out during a stroll. The 0.5-inch heel adds just enough lift without sacrificing comfort, making these ideal for errands or casual meetups.
I also appreciated how versatile they are; you can dress them up or down easily.
The leather upper is clearly of good quality, and with a quick polish, they looked fresh even after a long day. I recommend applying a few coats of transparent polish before you wear them for the first time—this keeps the leather soft and looking sharp.
The overall construction feels sturdy, and I’ve found them durable enough to handle daily use.
One thing to keep in mind is that the wide strap might feel a little snug if you have wider feet. Also, because they’re flat sandals, they aren’t the best choice if you need serious arch support.
Still, for casual outings and everyday comfort, these sandals hit the mark.
Amazon Essentials Women’s Casual Strappy Sandal, Black, 8.5
- ✓ Stylish leather-like appearance
- ✓ Comfortable padded insole
- ✓ Adjustable ankle strap
- ✕ Not very breathable
- ✕ Slight heel discomfort after long wear
| Upper Material | Faux leather with dip-dyed finish and natural burnishing |
| Insole | Padded with latex foam for comfort |
| Outsole | Flexible, durable, non-slip rubber |
| Heel Height | 1/4 inch |
| Width Options | Regular and wide-widths available |
| Closure | Adjustable ankle strap with hidden elastic |
Right out of the box, I was struck by how sleek these Amazon Essentials Women’s Casual Strappy Sandals look. The dip-dyed upper with its burnished finish immediately gives off an authentic leather vibe, but I knew I’d need to see if they held up in real wear.
Once I slipped them on, the adjustable ankle strap with its hidden elastic made for an easy, snug fit. The padded insole with latex foam felt surprisingly cushy—walking around all day didn’t turn into a pain fest.
The 1/4 inch heel added just enough lift without sacrificing stability.
The faux leather material is soft and flexible, letting your foot move naturally. I appreciated how lightweight they are, making it feel almost like I wasn’t wearing anything at all.
The non-slip sole gave me confidence on slick surfaces, and I liked how the whole thing held together after hours of use.
Pairing these with everything from casual jeans to summer dresses was effortless. They’re versatile enough to take you from a beach stroll to a dinner date without missing a beat.
Plus, the wide-width option is a win for wider feet, preventing pinching or discomfort.
That said, the faux leather isn’t as breathable as genuine leather, so they might feel a bit warm on very hot days. Also, the 1/4 inch heel isn’t high, but it’s enough to cause slight discomfort if you’re on your feet all day, especially if you’re not used to heels.
What Makes a Black Strappy Sandal the Best Choice?
The best black strappy sandal stands out for its versatility, comfort, and style.
- Versatility: Black strappy sandals can be dressed up or down, making them suitable for various occasions, from casual outings to formal events. Their neutral color complements a wide range of outfits, allowing for easy pairing with dresses, shorts, or jeans.
- Comfort: Many black strappy sandals are designed with comfort in mind, featuring cushioned footbeds and adjustable straps. This ensures a secure fit, reducing the likelihood of discomfort during extended wear, which is essential for busy days or nights out.
- Style: The strappy design of these sandals adds an element of sophistication and elegance. They often come in various styles, including flat, heeled, or wedge options, appealing to different fashion tastes and preferences.
- Breathability: With an open design, black strappy sandals allow for airflow, keeping feet cool and comfortable, especially in warmer weather. This makes them a practical choice for summer outings or beach trips.
- Durability: High-quality black strappy sandals are made from materials such as leather or synthetic alternatives that offer durability. This ensures that they can withstand regular wear while maintaining their shape and style over time.
What Key Features Should Every Black Strappy Sandal Have?
The best black strappy sandals should incorporate several key features to ensure style, comfort, and versatility.
- Adjustable Straps: Adjustable straps are essential for providing a customized fit, which enhances comfort and stability while walking. This feature allows the wearer to modify the tightness across the ankle or foot, accommodating different foot shapes and sizes.
- Cushioned Footbed: A cushioned footbed is crucial for all-day wear, as it offers support and reduces fatigue during prolonged use. Look for sandals with memory foam or gel inserts that conform to the foot’s shape, providing additional comfort and shock absorption.
- Durable Outsole: A durable outsole made from rubber or high-quality synthetic materials ensures better traction and longevity. This feature is particularly important for strappy sandals that may be worn on various surfaces, allowing for safe movement without slipping.
- Versatile Design: A versatile design allows black strappy sandals to be dressed up or down, making them suitable for various occasions. This includes a sleek silhouette and neutral color, enabling pairs to match effortlessly with different outfits, from casual to formal wear.
- Breathability: Breathability is important in sandal design to keep feet cool and dry, especially during warmer months. Look for designs that incorporate open-toe styles or materials that allow for airflow, which can prevent discomfort and sweating during wear.
- Lightweight Construction: A lightweight construction contributes to overall comfort, making it easier to wear sandals for extended periods. Heavier sandals can cause fatigue, so opting for lighter materials helps maintain energy levels throughout the day.
How Important are Material Choices for Comfort and Durability?
Material choices play a crucial role in the comfort and durability of the best black strappy sandals.
- Leather: Leather is a popular choice for strappy sandals due to its natural breathability and ability to mold to the wearer’s foot over time. It offers a luxurious feel and can withstand wear and tear, making it a durable option for daily use.
- Synthetic Fabrics: Synthetic materials such as polyester or nylon are often used for their lightweight properties and water-resistant features. While they may not have the same longevity as leather, they can provide added comfort, especially in casual styles, and are typically easier to clean.
- Cork Soles: Cork is favored for sandal soles due to its shock-absorbing capabilities and lightweight nature. It conforms to the foot’s shape, enhancing comfort during prolonged wear while also being eco-friendly.
- Rubber: Rubber is commonly used for outsoles because of its excellent traction and durability. Sandals with rubber soles can withstand various terrains and offer a reliable grip, making them ideal for both urban and outdoor environments.
- Foam Padding: Incorporating foam padding in the footbed can significantly enhance comfort by providing cushioning and support. This feature is particularly beneficial for those who plan to wear sandals for extended periods, as it helps reduce foot fatigue.
What Strap Designs Provide the Best Fit and Style?
When searching for the best black strappy sandal, several strap designs stand out for their fit and style:
- Classic T-Strap: This design features a vertical strap that runs down the center of the foot, connecting to a horizontal strap across the toes. It offers excellent support while elongating the leg, making it a flattering choice for various outfits.
- Ankle Strap: Ankle strap sandals secure around the ankle, providing stability and comfort. They can be adjusted for a better fit and come in various widths, allowing for a customizable look that can range from casual to sophisticated.
This design includes a long strap that wraps around the ankle or calf, creating a stylish and secure fit. It adds a bohemian flair to the sandal and can be tied in various ways, giving the wearer flexibility in styling. - Cage Sandal: Cage sandals feature multiple straps that create a sophisticated and edgy look, often resembling a gladiator style. They provide ample support and coverage while still being fashionable, making them suitable for both day and night wear.
- Slide Sandal: Slide sandals are characterized by their open back and minimal straps across the front, offering easy wearability. They provide a casual yet chic option that can be dressed up or down, making them versatile for summer outings.
Where Can You Buy the Best Black Strappy Sandals?
When searching for the best black strappy sandals, several popular retailers offer a wide variety to choose from:
- Amazon: Known for its extensive selection, Amazon provides numerous brands and styles of black strappy sandals, often accompanied by user reviews and ratings to help guide your purchase.
- Nordstrom: This retailer is renowned for its quality footwear selection, featuring a range of designer black strappy sandals that combine style with comfort, perfect for both casual and formal occasions.
- Zappos: Zappos specializes in shoes and offers a wide variety of black strappy sandals along with free shipping and returns, making it easy to find the perfect fit and style.
- DSW: Designer Shoe Warehouse (DSW) has a great selection of black strappy sandals at competitive prices, often providing discounts and a rewards program for frequent shoppers.
- ASOS: This online fashion retailer frequently updates its collection with trendy black strappy sandals, catering to a younger demographic looking for stylish options at affordable prices.
Amazon stands out for its vast inventory and customer reviews, allowing shoppers to compare different styles and price points easily. The convenience of fast shipping and a comprehensive return policy enhances the shopping experience.
Nordstrom offers a curated collection of high-quality sandals, often featuring renowned brands that prioritize comfort and fashion. Their customer service is also highly rated, making it a reliable choice for those seeking premium options.
Zappos is a favorite for shoe enthusiasts due to its extensive range and customer-friendly policies. The ability to return items for free and the detailed product descriptions make it a hassle-free shopping destination.
DSW is an excellent option for those looking for trendy sandals without breaking the bank. With regular sales and a loyalty program, customers can find great deals on stylish footwear.
ASOS appeals to fashion-forward individuals, offering the latest trends in black strappy sandals at reasonable prices. Their frequent promotions and unique styles attract a younger audience eager to express their personal style.
What Are the Leading Brands for High-Quality Black Strappy Sandals?
The leading brands for high-quality black strappy sandals include:
- Sam Edelman: Known for their trendy and stylish designs, Sam Edelman offers black strappy sandals that combine comfort with contemporary fashion. Their sandals often feature unique detailing and are made with high-quality materials, making them suitable for both casual and dressy occasions.
- Steve Madden: A well-established brand in the footwear industry, Steve Madden provides a wide variety of black strappy sandals that cater to diverse tastes. Their designs range from sleek and minimalist to bold and eye-catching, ensuring there is something for everyone, often at an accessible price point.
- Stuart Weitzman: Renowned for luxury and elegance, Stuart Weitzman black strappy sandals are crafted from premium materials and designed with attention to detail. They typically feature classic silhouettes that can elevate any outfit, making them a favorite for special occasions and high-end events.
- Vince Camuto: Vince Camuto combines modern fashion with comfort in their black strappy sandals, making them ideal for everyday wear. Their sandals often include cushioned footbeds and adjustable straps, ensuring a good fit and lasting comfort throughout the day.
- Nine West: Offering stylish yet affordable options, Nine West is known for their trendy black strappy sandals that appeal to a wide audience. Their designs often incorporate current fashion trends, making them a go-to choice for those looking to stay chic without breaking the bank.
How Should You Style Black Strappy Sandals for Different Occasions?
The best black strappy sandals can be styled in various ways to suit different occasions.
- Casual Day Out: Pair your black strappy sandals with a flowy maxi dress or a loose-fitting jumpsuit for a relaxed look.
- Office Attire: Opt for tailored trousers and a crisp blouse, complemented by black strappy sandals to maintain a professional yet stylish appearance.
- Evening Dinner: Combine your sandals with a sleek little black dress or a chic midi dress for an elegant evening ensemble.
- Beach Outing: Style your sandals with a stylish swimsuit cover-up or a light sundress for a perfect beach-ready look.
- Brunch with Friends: Wear your black strappy sandals with high-waisted shorts and a trendy top, creating a comfortable and fashionable outfit.
For a casual day out, black strappy sandals can be effortlessly styled with a flowy maxi dress or a loose-fitting jumpsuit. This combination offers a laid-back vibe while still looking put together, perfect for a stroll in the park or a shopping trip.
When curating an office attire, black strappy sandals can enhance tailored trousers and a crisp blouse. This pairing strikes the right balance between professionalism and style, allowing you to feel confident in a corporate setting.
For an evening dinner, black strappy sandals can be paired with a sleek little black dress or a chic midi dress for a sophisticated look. This combination exudes elegance and is suitable for various dining venues, from casual to upscale restaurants.
At the beach, black strappy sandals can be styled with a fashionable swimsuit cover-up or a light sundress, creating an effortlessly chic beach look. This combination ensures comfort while allowing you to show off your sense of style as you relax by the water.
For a brunch with friends, black strappy sandals can be teamed with high-waisted shorts and a trendy top. This outfit is both comfortable and stylish, making it ideal for a leisurely weekend gathering.
Related Post: