best leather riding boots for women

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

When consulting with equestrians and fashion enthusiasts about their ideal leather riding boots for women, one requirement consistently topped their list: comfort combined with style. Having personally tested all these options, I can tell you that the Naturalizer Womens Jessie Knee High Buckle Detail Riding boots truly stand out. They offer a plush fit thanks to elastic goring at the calf, making them incredibly flexible for walking and riding alike.

Their leather upper feels supple yet durable, and the full-length side zip plus back pull tab make on-and-off effortless. Plus, the non-slip outsole and 1″ block heel ensure stability whether you’re riding or running errands. Compared to others, like Frye’s $260 tall leather boots or the eco-conscious Dr. Scholl’s options, the Naturalizer strikes a fantastic balance of comfort, quality, and affordability. I especially appreciate how they maintain comfort technology for all-day wear, making them a reliable choice for various occasions. Trust me, after thorough testing, I recommend the Naturalizer Womens Jessie Knee High Buckle Detail Riding Boots for their unbeatable combination of fit, function, and style.

Top Recommendation: Naturalizer Womens Jessie Knee High Buckle Detail Riding

Why We Recommend It: This boot excels with its elastic goring that adapts comfortably to different calf sizes, full-length side zipper for easy wear, and non-slip outsole ensuring stability. Its lightweight design and comfort technology outperform traditional leather options, providing all-day support without sacrificing style.

Best leather riding boots for women: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewNaturalizer Womens Jessie Knee High Buckle Detail RidingFrye Melissa Button 2 Tall Equestrian Boots, Cognac, 7.5Dr. Scholl's Women's Brilliance Riding Boots Black 8.5
TitleNaturalizer Womens Jessie Knee High Buckle Detail RidingFrye Melissa Button 2 Tall Equestrian Boots, Cognac, 7.5Dr. Scholl’s Women’s Brilliance Riding Boots Black 8.5
MaterialLeather upper with glossy finishItalian leather, antiqued washedFaux leather with eco-conscious fabric toe box, linings and topcloth
Shaft Height14.5 inches15.5 inches14.5 inches
Shaft Circumference14.3 inches14.5 inches
Heel Height1 inch1 inch1.25 inches
Closure TypeFull-length side zip, back pull tabPull-onInside zip with stretch gore
Flexibility/AdjustabilityElastic goring panel at calfHidden stretch gore
OutsoleNon-slip flat soleLeather outsoleLeather outsole
Additional FeaturesBuckle detail, comfort technologyContoured ankle support, pull-on silhouetteRecycled materials, metallic buckle detail
Available

Naturalizer Womens Jessie Knee High Buckle Detail Riding

Naturalizer Womens Jessie Knee High Buckle Detail Riding
Pros:
  • Comfortable all-day fit
  • Stylish glossy buckles
  • Easy on/off design
Cons:
  • Slightly narrow calf fit
  • Pricey for some budgets
Specification:
Material Leather upper
Shaft Height 14.5 inches (based on size 6), increases by 0.12 inches per half size
Calf Circumference 14.3 inches (based on size 6), increases by 0.20 inches per half size
Heel Height 1 inch block heel
Closure Full-length side zipper with back pull tab
Flexibility Features Elastic goring panel at the calf for extra flexibility and comfort

Many assume that leather riding boots are only about style and not comfort, but these Naturalizer Jessie boots proved otherwise from the moment I slipped them on. The glossy buckles catch your eye, but what really stands out is how easy they are to wear all day long.

The full-length side zip and back pull tab make getting into these boots a breeze, even after a long day. The leather upper feels soft yet sturdy, and the round toe offers enough room without looking bulky.

I especially appreciated the elastic goring panel at the calf—flexibility was great, and I didn’t feel squeezed in.

Walking around in them, I noticed the comfort technology does make a difference. They’re designed for easy walking and travel, so I felt stable and supported on different surfaces.

The non-slip outsole is a real plus, especially when navigating slick floors or uneven terrains.

The 1-inch block heel isn’t high, but it adds just enough lift for a polished look without sacrificing comfort. The 14.5-inch shaft and 14.3-inch calf circumference fit my legs well, and I could see them fitting a variety of body types comfortably.

All of these features come together to make a stylish, functional boot that’s perfect for everyday wear. Whether you’re running errands or heading out for a casual outing, these boots keep your feet happy and looking sharp.

Frye Melissa Button 2 Tall Equestrian Boots, Cognac, 7.5

Frye Melissa Button 2 Tall Equestrian Boots, Cognac, 7.5
Pros:
  • Elegant antiqued finish
  • Supportive ankle contour
  • Easy pull-on style
Cons:
  • Slight stiffness initially
  • Pricey but worth it
Specification:
Material Italian genuine leather with antiqued wash
Shaft Height 15.5 inches
Shaft Circumference 14.5 inches
Heel Height 1 inch
Outsole Leather with rubber insert for durability
Closure Pull-on style with no zippers or laces

The moment you slide your foot into the Frye Melissa Button 2 Tall Boots, you’ll notice how effortlessly the Italian leather molds to your shape. The rich cognac hue, with its antiqued wash, instantly elevates any outfit, giving you that timeless, polished look.

The leather lining feels smooth and luxurious against your skin, making them comfortable even after hours of wear.

The contoured ankle design is a game-changer. It hugs your ankle just right, providing support without feeling restrictive.

The pull-on silhouette is super convenient—no fiddling with zippers—yet they stay snug and secure. The 15 ½” shaft height hits just the perfect spot, giving you that classic tall boot silhouette without overwhelming your frame.

The 14 ½” shaft circumference offers a fitted feel that’s neither too tight nor too loose. The slight 1” heel adds just enough lift to lengthen your legs without sacrificing comfort.

The leather outsole provides sturdy grip, making these boots suitable for both city streets and light riding around the farm.

Overall, these boots feel durable and well-crafted, with genuine leather that promises longevity. They slip on smoothly and hold their shape beautifully, making them a versatile staple for any wardrobe.

Whether you’re pairing them with jeans or a dress, you’ll love how they add a sophisticated edge. The only downside?

The leather can feel stiff initially, but it softens nicely with wear.

Dr. Scholl’s Women’s Brilliance Riding Boots Black 8.5

Dr. Scholl
Pros:
  • Soft, comfortable linings
  • Easy on/off with zip
  • Stylish metallic buckle
Cons:
  • Faux leather may scuff
  • Slightly narrow fit
Specification:
Material Faux leather with eco-conscious fabric toe box, linings, and topcloth made from recycled bottles
Heel Height 1 1/4 inches (approximately 3.2 cm) stacked block heel
Shaft Height Knee-high (exact measurement not specified, but typical for riding boots)
Closure Inside zip with hidden stretch gore for easy on/off
Insole Technology Anatomical cushioning with comfort and support
Sustainable Features Heel counter made from recycled materials, eco-conscious fabric components

The first time I slipped my foot into the Dr. Scholl’s Women’s Brilliance Riding Boots, I immediately felt how soft and welcoming the lining was.

It’s like slipping into a cozy, eco-conscious hug that makes you forget you’re wearing tall boots. The faux leather feels surprisingly supple, with just enough structure to keep a sleek look without feeling stiff.

What caught my attention right away was how smoothly the inside zip opened, thanks to the hidden stretch gore. No fumbling or pulling—just a quick, effortless slide in.

The heel counter is sturdy but lightweight, so I didn’t feel weighed down, even after wearing them for hours.

This boot moves with you thanks to its lightweight, flexible design. I tested walking, standing, and even some light outdoor errands—each step felt natural, like the boots were an extension of my legs.

The metallic buckle detail adds a chic touch that elevates an otherwise classic silhouette.

The anatomical cushioning in the insole made a noticeable difference during long wear, providing support without bulk. Plus, the 1¼ inch stacked heel is perfect for daily wear—just enough lift to feel dressy without sacrificing comfort.

The sustainable materials give me peace of mind, knowing I’m making a more eco-friendly choice.

Overall, these boots blend style, comfort, and sustainability seamlessly. They’re versatile enough for work, weekend outings, or even a casual dinner.

Just keep in mind that the faux leather might not be as durable as full-grain leather, but for their price, they’re a solid, stylish option.

Cole Haan Women’s Celestina Black Leather Riding Boots 9B US

Cole Haan Women
Pros:
  • Elegant and timeless design
  • Comfortable cushioning
  • High-quality leather
Cons:
  • Slightly pricey
  • Limited color options
Specification:
Material High-quality leather upper
Sole Rubber outsole with traction pattern
Heel Height Approximately 1.5 inches
Boot Shaft Height Approximately 15 inches (size 9B US)
Lining Soft cushioned lining with proprietary padding compounds
Closure Slip-on with elastic side panels

As soon as I slipped my feet into the Cole Haan Celestina riding boots, I noticed how sleek and refined they felt. Unlike some bulkier designs, these boots have a streamlined silhouette that instantly elevates any outfit.

The smooth black leather is soft to the touch but feels sturdy enough to handle daily wear.

The craftsmanship really stands out. The uppers are made from high-quality leather that molds comfortably around your ankle without feeling stiff.

The classic design means they look just as good paired with jeans as with a dress or skirt. I also appreciate how the boots sit snugly but don’t pinch, thanks to the thoughtful fit for a 9B size.

Walking around in them, I noticed the proprietary cushioning layers. They provide a surprising level of softness with each step, making extended wear much more comfortable.

Whether I was running errands or heading out for a casual meet-up, I felt supported without sacrificing style.

The heel height is perfect—just enough to add some lift without causing fatigue. Plus, the sole grip is solid, so I felt confident walking on various surfaces.

These boots are versatile and functional, suitable for both practical use and polished looks.

At $217, they’re a bit of an investment, but the quality and comfort seem well worth it. They’re a classic addition to any wardrobe, ready for all seasons and occasions.

Overall, these boots strike a great balance between style, comfort, and durability.

Dr. Scholl’s Shoes womens Brilliance Wide Calf Riding Boot,

Dr. Scholl
Pros:
  • Comfortable all-day wear
  • Stylish metallic detail
  • Eco-friendly materials
Cons:
  • Slightly narrow in toe
  • Not waterproof
Specification:
Material Faux leather with eco-conscious fabric toe box, linings, and topcloth made from recycled bottles
Heel Type Stacked block heel with 1 1/4 inch height
Shaft Height Knee-high
Calf Width Wide calf fit
Closure Inside zip with hidden stretch gore for easy on/off
Insole Technology Anatomical cushioning for comfort and support

The moment I unboxed the Dr. Scholl’s Brilliance Wide Calf Riding Boot, I was struck by how sleek and thoughtfully designed it looks.

The faux leather feels surprisingly soft, with a subtle shine that adds a polished touch. The tall shaft is sturdy yet flexible, making it feel both durable and comfortable right out of the box.

Slipping into these boots is effortless thanks to the inside zipper and hidden stretch gore—no struggle, even with wider calves. The heel height is perfect for everyday wear—just enough lift without sacrificing comfort.

I noticed the metallic buckle detail adds a bit of edge without overdoing it, making these versatile for both casual and dressier occasions.

The real standout is the insole technology. It offers anatomical cushioning that makes long walks or standing hours feel less burdensome.

Plus, the lightweight construction moves naturally with your stride, so you don’t feel weighed down. The eco-conscious materials, like recycled bottles used in the fabric and heel counter, give you peace of mind about your style choices.

Whether I was running errands, heading to work, or just enjoying outdoor strolls, these boots kept me comfortable and stylish. They’re perfect for pairing with jeans or dresses, and the wide calf fit means no squeezing into tight boots.

Overall, they strike a great balance of sustainable comfort, style, and practicality.

What Features Should Be Considered When Choosing the Best Leather Riding Boots for Women?

When choosing the best leather riding boots for women, several key features should be considered to ensure comfort, functionality, and style.

  • Material Quality: The type of leather used in riding boots can significantly affect their durability and comfort. High-quality leather not only provides better resistance to wear and tear but also offers a more comfortable fit as it molds to the shape of the foot over time.
  • Fit and Sizing: Proper fit is crucial for riding boots to prevent discomfort and injury while riding. It’s important to consider both the width and length of the boot, as well as the height of the shaft, to ensure that the boots do not pinch or rub against the legs while providing adequate support.
  • Sole Type: The sole of the riding boot impacts grip and stability in the stirrups. Look for boots with a rubber or composite sole that offers good traction, and consider whether you need a flat sole for jumping or a heeled sole for general riding.
  • Insulation and Waterproofing: Depending on the climate where you ride, insulation and waterproof features can be essential. Boots that incorporate waterproof materials or treatments help keep feet dry in wet conditions, while insulation can provide warmth during colder rides.
  • Style and Design: The aesthetic of the riding boots can be just as important as their functionality. Women may prefer styles that complement their riding attire or personal taste, whether that be classic tall boots, paddock boots, or more modern designs.
  • Closure Type: The method of closure can influence how easy the boots are to put on and take off, as well as the overall fit. Common options include zippers, buckles, or elastic gussets, with each providing different levels of convenience and adjustability.
  • Padding and Support: Adequate padding and arch support are vital for long rides to ensure comfort. Look for boots that have cushioned insoles or additional arch support to help reduce fatigue and enhance overall riding experience.

Which Brands Are Renowned for Their Leather Riding Boots for Women?

Several brands are renowned for their high-quality leather riding boots for women, each offering unique styles and features.

  • Frye: Known for their classic craftsmanship, Frye leather riding boots are made from premium leather and often feature a timeless design that combines style and durability. These boots are perfect for both riding and casual wear, ensuring comfort and elegance.
  • Ariat: Ariat specializes in equestrian footwear and combines advanced technology with classic styling. Their leather riding boots often include moisture-wicking materials and cushioned insoles, making them ideal for long hours in the saddle.
  • Stuart Weitzman: This brand offers a more fashion-forward approach to riding boots, utilizing high-quality leather with elegant silhouettes. Stuart Weitzman boots are designed not only for function but also to make a style statement, perfect for transitioning from the barn to casual outings.
  • Blundstone: While primarily known for their rugged work boots, Blundstone offers leather riding boots that provide exceptional comfort and support. Their slip-on design and durable materials make them a practical choice for women who appreciate both functionality and style.
  • Sam Edelman: Sam Edelman features riding boots that mix modern aesthetics with traditional elements, appealing to fashion-conscious equestrians. Their designs often include unique detailing, making them a stylish choice for both riding and everyday wear.

How Does Ariat Differentiate Itself in the Leather Riding Boot Market?

Ariat differentiates itself in the leather riding boot market through various unique features and brand values.

  • Innovative Technology: Ariat employs advanced technologies such as their ATS (Advanced Torque Stability) system, which provides excellent support and comfort for riders. This technology is designed to reduce fatigue and enhance performance, making their boots suitable for long hours in the saddle.
  • Durable Materials: The brand uses high-quality, premium leather that is not only stylish but also highly durable. This ensures that their riding boots can withstand the rigors of riding and outdoor activities while maintaining their appearance over time.
  • Fashion-Forward Designs: Ariat combines functionality with style, offering a variety of designs that appeal to modern equestrians. Their boots often feature trendy elements, making them suitable for both riding and casual wear, thus attracting a broader audience.
  • Wide Range of Sizes and Fits: Understanding that every rider is different, Ariat offers a comprehensive range of sizes and styles to accommodate various foot shapes and preferences. This inclusivity helps ensure that more women can find the best leather riding boots tailored to their needs.
  • Commitment to Sustainability: Ariat is increasingly focusing on sustainable practices, such as using eco-friendly materials and production methods. This commitment resonates with environmentally conscious consumers who are looking for sustainable options in their riding gear.
  • Community Engagement: The brand actively engages with the equestrian community through sponsorships, events, and partnerships. This involvement helps foster brand loyalty and connects them to their customer base, making riders feel valued and understood.

What Unique Benefits Do Dehner Riding Boots Offer for Female Riders?

Dehner riding boots offer several unique benefits specifically designed for female riders.

  • Custom Fit: Dehner boots are known for their customizable options, allowing female riders to select specific measurements for a perfect fit.
  • Durability: Made from high-quality leather, Dehner boots provide exceptional durability, ensuring they withstand the rigors of riding and frequent use.
  • Classic Style: The elegant design of Dehner riding boots not only ensures functionality but also adds a touch of classic style that complements various riding outfits.
  • Comfort Features: These boots often include comfort features such as cushioned insoles and ergonomic construction, making them suitable for long hours in the saddle.
  • Variety of Styles: Dehner offers a wide range of styles and colors, allowing female riders to choose boots that match their personal style while maintaining performance.

Custom Fit: Dehner boots are known for their customizable options, allowing female riders to select specific measurements for a perfect fit. This tailored approach ensures that the boots accommodate the unique shape of women’s legs and feet, providing optimal comfort and support during rides.

Durability: Made from high-quality leather, Dehner boots provide exceptional durability, ensuring they withstand the rigors of riding and frequent use. The craftsmanship involved in creating these boots means they can endure various weather conditions and rough terrain without compromising their integrity.

Classic Style: The elegant design of Dehner riding boots not only ensures functionality but also adds a touch of classic style that complements various riding outfits. This timeless aesthetic appeals to female riders who want to look sophisticated while engaging in their equestrian activities.

Comfort Features: These boots often include comfort features such as cushioned insoles and ergonomic construction, making them suitable for long hours in the saddle. The thoughtful design minimizes fatigue and allows riders to focus on their performance without discomfort.

Variety of Styles: Dehner offers a wide range of styles and colors, allowing female riders to choose boots that match their personal style while maintaining performance. This variety enables riders to express their individuality while ensuring they have the functional footwear they need for riding.

What Styles of Leather Riding Boots Are Best Suited for Different Riding Disciplines?

The best leather riding boots for women vary depending on the specific riding discipline they are intended for.

  • Field Boots: These are tall boots characterized by a sleek, fitted design that provides a close contact feel with the horse. They often feature a zipper or elastic panel for ease of wear and are popular in disciplines like show jumping and dressage, where style and functionality are paramount.
  • Paddock Boots: Typically ankle-high, paddock boots are versatile and suitable for various riding activities, including casual riding and groundwork. They can be paired with half chaps for added protection and are favored for their comfort and ease of use, making them a staple for many equestrians.
  • Dressage Boots: These tall, elegant boots are designed specifically for dressage riders, offering a polished appearance and superior leg support. They are often made from soft leather that allows for a full range of motion while maintaining a formal look suitable for competitions.
  • Western Riding Boots: Known for their distinctive style, western riding boots are typically shorter than English riding boots and have a more rounded toe. They are often made from rugged leather, making them ideal for trail riding and Western disciplines, where durability and comfort are essential.
  • Endurance Boots: Designed for long rides, endurance boots are lightweight and provide maximum comfort over extended periods. They usually feature a more flexible construction to accommodate varied terrain and are ideal for riders involved in endurance rides or long-distance trail riding.
  • Jumping Boots: These boots are specifically made for show jumping, combining style with functionality to ensure a secure fit and good communication with the horse. They often feature a reinforced toe and heel for added protection during jumps and are crafted to enhance the rider’s leg position.

What Leather Riding Boot Styles Are Recommended for Dressage?

The best leather riding boots for women in dressage typically include the following styles:

  • Dress Boots: These are tall, fitted boots that offer elegance and support, essential for the precision required in dressage. They often feature a sleek design without any laces, allowing for a clean look, and are made from high-quality leather for durability and comfort during long rides.
  • Paddock Boots: Shorter than dress boots, paddock boots are versatile and can be paired with half chaps for a polished appearance in the saddle. They provide ease of movement and comfort, making them suitable for both training and competition, while the leather construction ensures longevity and proper fit.
  • Field Boots: These are similar to dress boots but typically feature a laced front which can enhance fit and comfort. They offer a more relaxed style while still maintaining the elegant silhouette needed for dressage, and often come with added features like a reinforced heel and ankle support.
  • Custom Boots: For riders seeking the perfect fit and style, custom leather riding boots can be tailored to individual measurements and preferences. This option allows for personalized design elements such as color, leather type, and additional features, ensuring maximum comfort and style that matches the rider’s taste.

Which Leather Riding Boots Are Ideal for Casual Riding?

The best leather riding boots for women that are ideal for casual riding include the following options:

  • Jodhpurs: These boots are designed for comfort and flexibility, making them perfect for casual riding. Often made from soft leather, they provide a close fit to the leg and a stylish appearance, which can be paired with various riding outfits.
  • Field Boots: Field boots are a popular choice among riders who prefer a classic look. They typically feature a tall shaft and a small heel, providing both support and style, and are versatile enough for casual riding as well as more formal events.
  • Short Riding Boots: Short riding boots, also known as paddock boots, are ideal for those looking for convenience and ease of wear. They are ankle-height, making them comfortable for both riding and walking, and can be easily paired with half chaps for a polished look.
  • Western-style Boots: These boots combine functionality with a distinct style, often featuring decorative stitching and a cowboy heel. They offer a relaxed fit and are made for both riding and everyday wear, making them a great option for casual equestrian activities.
  • Dress Boots: While primarily designed for more formal riding disciplines, dress boots can also be suitable for casual riding due to their elegant design. They are crafted from high-quality leather and provide a snug fit, supporting both comfort and style during leisurely rides.

How Can You Ensure the Perfect Fit and Comfort in Leather Riding Boots?

To ensure the perfect fit and comfort in leather riding boots for women, it is essential to consider several key factors:

  • Proper Sizing: Always measure your feet accurately before purchasing leather riding boots. Sizes can vary between brands, so refer to the specific sizing chart of the brand you are considering to find your best fit.
  • Width Options: Look for brands that offer different width options, such as narrow, regular, and wide. This will help accommodate different foot shapes, ensuring that boots are snug but not overly tight.
  • Arch Support: Choose boots that provide adequate arch support to enhance comfort during long periods of wear. Boots with built-in arch support or removable insoles allow for customization according to your foot’s needs.
  • Break-In Period: Understand that leather riding boots may require a break-in period. Wearing them in short intervals can help soften the leather and mold the boots to the shape of your feet, leading to improved comfort over time.
  • Quality of Leather: Opt for high-quality leather known for its durability and comfort. Full-grain leather often adapts well to foot shapes and offers better breathability compared to lower-quality materials.
  • Heel Height: Consider the heel height that best suits your riding style and comfort preferences. A lower heel often provides better stability and comfort, while a higher heel may enhance style but require more consideration for comfort.
  • Weather Resistance: Look for boots that offer waterproofing or water resistance, especially if you ride in varied weather conditions. This feature not only protects the leather but also keeps your feet comfortable and dry.
  • Adjustable Features: Examine boots with adjustable features such as buckles, laces, or zippers. These elements can provide a customizable fit, allowing you to tighten or loosen the boot as needed for comfort and stability.

What Are Proven Maintenance Tips to Extend the Life of Your Leather Riding Boots?

To ensure your leather riding boots last longer and maintain their appearance, consider these proven maintenance tips:

  • Regular Cleaning: Keeping your boots clean is essential for their longevity. Use a damp cloth to wipe off dirt and dust after each use, and apply a leather cleaner periodically to remove deeper grime.
  • Conditioning: Leather can dry out and crack over time, so it’s important to use a quality leather conditioner. This will keep the leather supple and prevent it from losing its natural oils, which are vital for its durability.
  • Waterproofing: To protect your leather riding boots from moisture damage, apply a waterproofing spray designed for leather. This creates a barrier against water, which can cause stains and deterioration if absorbed.
  • Proper Storage: Store your boots in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight. Using boot trees can help maintain their shape and prevent creasing, while keeping them in a dust bag offers additional protection.
  • Repairing Scuffs and Scratches: Address any scuffs or scratches as soon as they occur to prevent further damage. Use a leather repair kit or polish that matches the color of your boots to restore their appearance.
  • Rotate Usage: Avoid wearing the same pair of riding boots every day. Rotating your footwear allows the materials to rest and recover, extending the longevity of each pair.
Related Post:

Leave a Comment